American Idol Surprise

Did anyone else watch American Idol last night? If so, were you rather surprised that Carly got voted off? I really like Brooke and Jason both, but I think that Carly did better than each of them. Over the weeks, I would say she's been much more consistent. I guess it goes to show that this television show is not only a "singing" competition as Simon always says...but also a "popularity contest" too. I think it's all a matter of who has the larger fan base. That's why you just never know with this show. Just because someone does poorly for many weeks in a row...doesn't necessarily mean they will get eliminated. We'll have to see what happens next week...